Bridging Academia and Industry: Mentors in the Evolution of I/O Psychology

Team IIBP Anveshan, Business Psychology, Coaching, Issue 51

“Every stage of your career requires different skills and insights. The right mentor at each phase will help you grow, adapt, and succeed in ways you never thought possible.” – Marissa Mayer
“The science of I-O psychology helps us understand that the key to business success lies in understanding people, not just processes.” – Edwin A. Fleishman

Is Industrial-Organizational (I/O) Psychology one of the least pursued branches of psychology in India? Do only a few large-scale organizations or corporations in the country recognize the need for psychologists in the workplace? Are there truly no job prospects or opportunities for I/O Psychologists in India? And why are MBAs in HR often preferred over I/O Psychologists?

These are some of the most common questions, and the stereotypical answer often heard in the psychology community is that a lack of opportunities, job security, and limited scope discourages thousands of students and professionals from pursuing this field. But have we ever paused to reflect and challenge the fundamental reasons why I/O Psychology exists and the dynamic career paths it offers?

Let’s consider this from the perspective of India’s economic and demographic trends. India’s economy is projected to grow robustly, with estimates for the fiscal year 2024-25 ranging from 6.5% to 7.2% in real GDP growth (PIB, 2023). Coupled with a growing working-age population, the demand for jobs will be significantly higher. Yet, 28% of graduates were unemployed in 2022, underscoring a mismatch between education and job opportunities (Indian Employment Report, 2024).

There is a clear trend of specialized HR functions branching out into distinct departments, separate from traditional HR roles focused on payroll and administration. This has created an increased demand for assessors, job designers, workforce and change agents, well-being specialists, psychometricians, learning specialists, and organizational development experts. In essence, identifying, assessing, and unlocking potential at the individual, team, and organizational levels is becoming increasingly vital. This is where qualified and skilled I/O Psychologists can play a crucial role in driving the growth of Indian employees, employers, and industries.

However, significant gaps exist at both the academic and industry levels. In the following section, we’ll explore these gaps and discuss how mentors—qualified I/O Psychologists and industry experts—can bridge the divide between academia and industry, bringing I/O Psychology to the forefront in India.

The Gap in Indian Academia on I/O Psychology

  1. The Dominance of U.S. Researchers in I/O Psychology Publications:
    An analysis of 5,626 papers published in the top 10 journals of I/O psychology over the last eleven years highlights a strong dominance of U.S. researchers. This trend persists despite a gradual increase in international contributions. The overwhelming influence of U.S. scholars limits the representation of diverse global perspectives, including those from India.
  2. Lack of Specialized Two-Year Programs in I/O Psychology:
    Most universities and colleges in India do not offer dedicated two-year programs specifically focused on I/O psychology. The absence of such specialized courses restricts students’ opportunities to delve deeply into this field, leading to a gap in expertise and career prospects.
  3. Insufficient Industry-Centric Training and Placement Opportunities:
    There is a notable lack of industry-focused training programs and effective placement schemes in Indian institutions for I/O psychology students. This gap results in graduates being underprepared for the practical demands of the industry, which in turn affects their employability.

The Ground Reality of the Industry, I/O Psychology Graduates, and the Job Market

The majority of applied psychology or industrial-organizational (I/O) psychology curricula in India are highly theoretical. This leaves students and professionals with minimal industry-relevant skills, making it challenging to secure opportunities in corporate settings. Consequently, the employability of I/O psychology graduates in India has reached concerningly low levels.

  1. Skill Gaps:
    The curriculum often emphasizes theory over practical skills, such as data analysis, organizational development, and employee assessment, which are crucial in today’s job market. For example, students may learn about employee motivation theories but lack hands-on experience in applying these concepts within a workplace setting.
  2. Employability vs. Employable Graduates:
    While there is a demand for I/O psychologists, many graduates are not considered employable due to the disconnect between academic training and industry needs. For instance, a graduate may possess a solid understanding of psychological principles but may struggle with applying them in areas like talent management or change management.
  3. Inadequacy in Branding and Profiling as an I/O Psychologist:
    Graduates often fail to effectively market themselves as I/O psychologists, leading to a lack of recognition in the job market. Many are unaware of how to highlight their unique skill set in resumes or interviews, unlike other specialized professionals who clearly articulate their value proposition.
  4. Mental Clarity on What an I/O Psychologist Can Do:
    There is a widespread misconception that I/O psychology is synonymous with HR, which limits career possibilities. The lack of vocational training further exacerbates this issue, with students unsure of the various roles an I/O psychologist can pursue, such as organizational consulting, leadership development, or employee well-being programs.
  5. Salary Market:
    The salary expectations for I/O psychologists in India are often low due to the limited understanding of the field’s value. For example, many graduates find themselves accepting roles with salaries that do not reflect the complexity and importance of their expertise, especially when compared to counterparts in fields like data science or management.
  6. Unexplored Territory Beyond HR:
    The potential for I/O psychologists extends far beyond traditional HR roles, yet many graduates are unaware of opportunities in areas such as organizational design, employee engagement analytics, or executive coaching. This unexplored territory remains largely untapped due to a lack of exposure and guidance during their education.

How Mentors Can Play a Significant Role in the Evolution and Success of I/O Psychology

  1. Dedicated Vocational Training as an I/O Psychologist:
    Mentors can provide targeted training that goes beyond academic theory, equipping aspiring I/O Psychologists with practical skills needed in real-world settings. For example, a mentor could guide a trainee through the design and implementation of employee engagement surveys, teach them how to interpret a psychometric report and debrief clients, or teach them how to conduct a job analysis.
  2. Navigating the Job Market and I/O Psychology Maze:
    Mentors can share their personal experiences and strategies for breaking into the I/O Psychology job market. For instance, a mentor who successfully transitioned from academia to industry might share tips on how to tailor resumes and portfolios to attract potential employers in corporate settings. Or they can teach to handle rejections and create a dynamic pitch to highlight how hiring an I/O Psychologist can benefit the company.
  3. Building Deep Subject Matter Expertise in a World of Generalists:
    In an environment where HR generalists often dominate, mentors can help I/O Psychologists develop specialized expertise. An example might be a mentor guiding a mentee in becoming a psychometric expert, enabling them to offer unique value in designing tools, and competency frameworks and assessing employee potential and performance.
  4. Translating Theoretical Concepts into Workable Strategies:
    Mentors can assist in bridging the gap between theory and practice by helping mentees translate academic knowledge into actionable business strategies. For example, a mentor might work with a mentee to develop a leadership development program that aligns with a company’s strategic goals, showing how theoretical models can drive real-world outcomes.

The above image highlights the need for a more rooted partnership between Industry and Academia to bring I/O psychology to the forefront in India!

Conclusion

“The true test of knowledge is not in what we learn, but in how we apply it to create meaningful change.”

The evolution and success of I/O Psychology in India hinge on bridging the gap between academia and industry. Mentors are key to this transformation. By offering vocational training, guiding career navigation, fostering deep expertise, and translating theory into actionable strategies, they can play a crucial role in re-shaping I/O Psychology in India. As India’s economy grows and diversifies, the demand for skilled I/O Psychologists will only increase. By empowering the next generation through mentorship, we can unlock the true potential of I/O Psychology and its impact on Indian workplaces.

References:

  1. Springer Nature. (2019). The dominance of I/O psychology by US publishers. Scientometrics, 121(2), 789-814. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-019-03180-2
  2. Press Information Bureau, Government of India. (2023). India’s economic outlook for 2023-2024. https://static.pib.gov.in/WriteReadData/specificdocs/documents/2024/jul/doc2024722351601.pdf
  3. International Labour Organization. (2024). India Employment Report 2024. http://www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/India%20Employment%20Report%202024.pdf
  4. Springer Nature. (2024). Student’s motivations behind not pursuing industrial/organizational psychology. Frontiers in Psychology, 15, Article 189. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44202-024-00189-4

About the Author